Why Employees Aren’t Using Their Group Health Insurance And How to Fix It

But, why is this happening?

Here are some key reasons:

✔ Lack of Communication – Many employees don’t receive clear information about their insurance benefits, coverage limits, and claim processes.
✔ Complicated Claim Process – If the claims process feels overwhelming, employees may choose to pay instead of navigating paperwork.
✔ Misconceptions About Coverage – Some believe their insurance doesn’t cover specific treatments, when in reality, it does.
✔ Low Engagement – Employees often forget about their insurance until they urgently need it, by which time they might not know how to use it effectively.

Let's take an example of Swapnil. Swapnil works at a leading fintech company that offers comprehensive health insurance to all employees. However, when enrollment time comes around, he hesitates. He’s unsure if the policy covers his specific needs, worries about claim hassles, and isn’t fully aware of the benefits. Eventually, he skips signing up, assuming he won’t need it.

Swapnil’s dilemma is common across workplaces. Despite companies providing group health insurance (GHI), many employees either don’t enroll or underutilize their coverage. This impacts both the employee’s financial security and the company’s overall productivity. 

Why Employees Hesitate to Use Group Health Insurance

Many employees hesitate to use their Group Health Insurance (GHI), often due to misconceptions and barriers that make it seem more complicated than it actually is. Lack of communication, complex claim processes, misconceptions about coverage, or simply low engagement all contribute to this hesitation. Understanding these challenges is the first step in ensuring employees fully utilize the healthcare benefits available to them.

Let’s explore the  reasons further.

Understanding Group Health Insurance Utilization: Trends and Challenges

Declining Enrollment in Employer-Sponsored Health Insurance

Between 2020 and 2021, private-sector employees covered by employer-sponsored health insurance declined from 49.5% to 48.0%. Enrollment rates varied significantly, with only 27.1% coverage at small employers compared to 56.3% at large employers. Despite the availability of group health insurance (GHI), many employees hesitate to use it due to various barriers, affecting overall healthcare accessibility.

Rising Costs and Financial Burden

Employers’ contributions to health insurance surged from $7,603 to $16,253 in 2021, increasing from 10% to 18% of household income. At the same time, deductible costs skyrocketed from $545 to over $3,000, requiring enrollees to pay approximately 3% of their household income before coverage applies. In 2024, 32% of covered workers face a general deductible of $2,000 or more for single coverage. Additionally, 28% of workers with employer-sponsored insurance now have high-deductible health plans (HDHPs), shifting more financial responsibility onto employees.

Low Health Insurance Literacy (HIL)

A key barrier to GHI utilization is the lack of health insurance literacy. A study in the U.S. found that 51% of 15,168 respondents struggled to understand health insurance concepts, while 48% lacked confidence in using their insurance. Without proper education and communication, employees may underutilize or completely forgo their benefits.

Enrollment Trends and Participation Gaps

In 2024, Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs) remain the most popular choice, with 48% of covered workers enrolled, followed by HDHPs with savings options (27%), Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) (13%), Point-of-Service (POS) plans (11%), and conventional plans (1%). Despite nearly 90% of employees working at firms that offer health benefits, only 61% of them are actually enrolled. Of those eligible for coverage, only 75% opt in, highlighting gaps in participation.

Barriers to Group Health Insurance Utilization

Despite the availability of Group Health Insurance (GHI), several barriers prevent employees from fully utilizing their benefits. Addressing these challenges is key to enhancing employee well-being, workforce productivity, and overall job satisfaction.

1. Lack of Awareness

Many employees, particularly new hires, struggle to understand their health insurance benefits and how to access them. A recent survey found that nearly 40% of new employees felt inadequately informed about their health benefits during onboarding. Poor communication regarding plan changes, such as modifications to covered services or network providers, further reduces utilization. Imagine an employee unaware of a new telehealth option, spending unnecessary time and money on a clinic visit for a minor ailment. Clear, consistent, and accessible information is essential.

Calculate your salary hike to see the impact on your overall package. 

2. Inadequate Plan Design

Some GHI plans fail to offer comprehensive coverage, omitting dependent coverage, mental health services, preventive care, or telehealth options. This makes the plan less attractive to employees who may seek alternative coverage. For instance, if a plan excludes fertility treatments or mental health support, employees may either forgo care or look for better employer-sponsored benefits. Leading companies like Google and Microsoft have responded by offering enhanced wellness benefits, including on-site mental health support and family planning assistance, to attract and retain top talent.

3. Complex Claim Processes

Lengthy and complicated insurance claim procedures discourage employees from seeking reimbursements or accessing care. A study by the American Medical Association found that physicians spend an average of 14.9 hours per week on administrative tasks related to insurance billing. Employees facing similar burdens may avoid using their insurance altogether. Digital claims processing, simplified paperwork, and dedicated support teams can significantly improve utilization.

4. Social Stigma Around Mental Health

Concerns about workplace perception and privacy prevent many employees from using mental health services. A survey by the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) found that over 50% of employees have experienced mental health stigma at work. To counter this, organizations must foster a culture of openness, provide confidential access to resources, and promote employee assistance programs (EAPs). Companies like Johnson & Johnson have implemented mindfulness training and EAPs to reduce stigma and improve mental well-being.

5. Discontinuation of Coverage

Employees who resign or face termination lose their group health insurance, often leaving them uninsured during career transitions. This coverage gap can be particularly harmful for those with ongoing health needs. Offering options like COBRA continuation plans or short-term insurance coverage can help bridge this gap, providing financial and health security.

6. Lack of Control Over Coverage

Since employers determine plan options, employees may feel the coverage does not align with their individual healthcare needs. For example, an employee with a chronic illness may prefer a plan with lower deductibles and broader specialist access, whereas a healthier employee may want a high-deductible plan with lower premiums. Providing customizable health benefits or flexible spending accounts (FSAs) allows employees to tailor their coverage based on personal needs.

7. Insufficient Coverage Limits

Capped sum insured amounts may fail to cover rising medical expenses, particularly in high-cost urban healthcare settings. For instance, an employee requiring major surgery in a metro city might find that their GHI covers only a fraction of the cost, leading to substantial out-of-pocket expenses. Regularly reviewing coverage limits and offering top-up insurance options can mitigate this risk.

8. Systemic Barriers

Language barriers, low health literacy, and complex insurance policies make it difficult for employees to navigate their healthcare benefits. Employees unfamiliar with insurance terms or claim procedures may delay or avoid seeking care altogether. Providing multilingual resources, simplifying insurance jargon, and offering personalized benefits counseling can help employees make informed decisions.

9. Personal & Financial Constraints

Fear of bureaucratic hassles, financial limitations, lack of time, or transportation issues often discourage employees from utilizing healthcare benefits. Many may also believe that certain treatments won’t be effective. Addressing these concerns requires a multi-faceted approach, including:

• Streamlined administrative processes
• Financial assistance programs
• On-site or virtual healthcare options
• Evidence-based healthcare awareness programs

‍

The Hidden Cost of Employee Turnover: Why Benefits Matter More Than You Think

Employee turnover is at an all-time high, and the numbers are alarming. According to Gallup, 49% of employees are actively looking for a new job. Even more concerning, only 28% would recommend their previous workplace after leaving. This highlights a serious issue—employees aren’t just leaving for better pay; they’re leaving because they feel undervalued.

A major reason behind this dissatisfaction? Poor management. The Gallup data reveals that employees today are more likely to quit due to ineffective leadership. Lack of communication, micromanagement, and minimal support create a frustrating work environment, making employees disengage and seek better opportunities.

While improving management practices is crucial, offering meaningful employee benefits can also play a big role in retention. A strong group health insurance (GHI) plan isn’t just a perk—it’s a sign that an organization genuinely cares about its people. When employees feel supported, both professionally and personally, they are more likely to stay engaged and committed.

In today’s competitive job market, companies that invest in employee well-being through health benefits and a positive work culture have a clear advantage. The question isn’t just about why employees leave—it’s about what makes them stay.

The Impact of Underutilization

When employees avoid using their GHI, they face greater financial strain during medical emergencies, which can reduce productivity and work performance. HR managers play a critical role in bridging this gap by improving communication, simplifying processes, and educating employees about their benefits. Addressing these barriers can lead to better health outcomes and a more engaged workforce.

In conclusion, while Group Health Insurance (GHI) offers valuable benefits to employees, the underutilization of these plans remains a persistent issue. The key barriers, including lack of awareness, complicated claims processes, financial constraints, and inadequate plan design, all contribute to this challenge. It’s essential for both employers and insurance providers to address these concerns through better communication, streamlined processes, and more flexible coverage options. By tackling these issues head-on, companies can ensure that employees fully benefit from their GHI, improving both their health and overall productivity. Employers who prioritize effective GHI utilization not only enhance employee satisfaction but also strengthen their talent retention efforts in an increasingly competitive job market.

Key Points to Consider:

1. Barriers to Utilization: Employees hesitate to use GHI due to a lack of awareness, complex plans, confusing claims processes, and high costs.
2. Declining Enrollment: Low participation, especially in smaller companies, indicates gaps in GHI engagement.
3. Rising Costs: High deductibles and increasing out-of-pocket expenses discourage utilization.
4. Health Insurance Literacy: Many employees lack understanding, leading to underutilization.
5. Mental Health Stigma: Stigma surrounding mental health care prevents employees from using available resources.
6. Coverage Gaps: Employees face coverage loss during transitions, creating vulnerabilities.
7. Plan Design Issues: Limited coverage in areas such as mental health and preventive care reduces the appeal of GHI.
8. Systemic and Personal Barriers: Language, complexity, and financial constraints prevent full utilization.

Recommendations:

1. Simplify Communication: Provide clear, accessible information about benefits and plan changes.
2. Streamline Claims: Offer easy-to-navigate digital claims and dedicated support teams.
3. Expand Coverage: Include broader health services and regularly update coverage limits.
4. Improve Health Literacy: Offer educational resources and personalized support to enhance understanding.
5. Promote Mental Health Services: Address stigma and encourage the use of Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs) and wellness initiatives.‍
6. Provide Coverage Continuation: Offer options like COBRA to bridge gaps for employees transitioning out of the organization.